Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image

Affluent Investor | April 28, 2017

Scroll to top

Top

3 Comments

Why Goldman Sachs is Wrong on Gold

Jeffrey Currie

Wall Street powerhouse Goldman Sachs has recently reiterated its negative view on gold, which it has held for the past year. However, it is now doubling down on this view and advising clients to actually go short the metal. Jeff Currie, head of commodity research at Goldman, noted, “Our target is really driven by the view that we think that the Fed will ultimately be the dominate force here and put more downward pressure [on prices]”.

While I am in agreement with Goldman that the Fed will be the dominant force behind the price of gold, I believe the central bank will soon be back into the QE business, rather than raising interest rates and crushing the dollar price of gold.

Here’s why:

Since Nixon closed the gold window in 1971, gold has made an impressive move upward from its fixed price of $32 an ounce, to where it sits now around $1,250. But few seem to grasp what actually causes gold to move higher. An increase in the gold prices occurs when the market becomes convinced that a currency will lose its purchasing power due to central bank-induced money supply growth and real interest rates that have been forced into negative territory. And nothing convinces a market more of a rising gold price than when debt and deficits explode.

But while the parabolic move higher in gold from 2009 to 2011 did contain a period of low nominal interest rates, real rates did not fall. And, the surging gold price was not accompanied by a growing money supply either. In fact, the growth rate of M3 plummeted during 2009 thru 2010 — it wasn’t until 2011 that the money supply rebounded. So what would explain the steady move in gold from $800 to $1,900 per ounce during that time period? The gold price simply got ahead of itself because the market feared that out of control deficits would force the Federal Reserve into an unending cycle of debt monetization, which would engender a protracted period of negative real interest rates, booming money supply growth and inflation.

However, those fears were temporarily ameliorated by the reduction of Federal Budget deficits starting in 2011. This is because the Fed was, ironically, able to temporarily re-engineer asset bubbles, while sending borrowing costs lower, causing revenues to increase and expenditures to decrease. Annual deficits fell from $1.3 trillion in 2011, to $500 billion today. Adding to the gold market’s recent woes is the specious belief held by U.S. dollar bulls that the Fed will be aggressively raising interest rates while the rest of the world is cutting rates. This is the explanation to why gold and gold mining shares have suffered mightily during the past three years.

Today, the equity and bond markets have positioned themselves for the best outcomes of all possible scenarios. These markets are assured that the Fed can painlessly exit QE in October and real interest rates will rise with no ill effects on the economy. The pervasive belief being that US bonds, stocks and dollars will be the sole beacons of economic hope in an otherwise slumping worldwide economy; and, having complete faith that budget deficits will continue to shrink.

I don’t buy any of it, and here are the reasons:

Last week we learned that mortgage applications plunged to a 14 year low. This is because home prices are still so unaffordable that just a slight tick higher in interest rates is enough to stall both potential home buyers and borrowers looking to refinance their loans. This confirms that after six years of unprecedented Fed manipulation of markets, our economy has become hypersensitive to the slightest interest rate blip. It also supports my contention that the rise in rates which occurred during the second half of 2013, was much more influential on the first quarter’s negative 2.1 percent GDP print than what can be attributed to snow. Our economy is not anywhere near strong enough to sustain growth during a rising interest rate environment. And is why the Fed won’t venture very far into this game.

Furthermore, economies in Europe and Japan are in recession, while the once mighty emerging market economies are flailing. As their respective Central Banks frantically print money, the US dollar is soaring due to the belief that the US economy will remain unscathed from a global economic slowdown. But, the belief that the U.S. economy will stand alone on a pristine island, while Europe and Japan sinks into the sea, is just as preposterous and unprofitable as the belief held back in 2008 that economies around the world would remain untouched by the U.S. housing meltdown.

The markets also seemed to shrug off last week’s disappointing jobs report as an anomaly. Perhaps a colder-than-normal August is a good scapegoat. But this week, Janet Yellen gave us an interesting glimpse into the Fed’s view of the jobs picture with her “Labor Market Dash Board”. It showed that only three out of nine metrics regarding the labor market are better than they were prior to the start of the Great Recession. Investors should think again if they believe the Yellen Fed will be aggressively raising rates and boosting the value of the dollar given the labor market’s already-fragile condition.

Most importantly, the tide of shrinking budget deficits is about to turn. For instance, since 2011, we have seen a significant reduction in defense spending (down 5.5% during 2014 alone), due to the drawdown of troops in Iraq and Afghanistan. And although we have yet to learn the full costs associated with Obama’s plan to destroy ISIS–we can safely assume it will be very expensive.

Adding to this, is the drastically underestimated cost of Obamacare. Insurance risk pools failed to get the proper demographic mix, and the Cadillac tax–delayed until 2018–has companies scheming to redesign existing plans in order to avoid these taxes. Add to this the unexpected costs of illegals flooding the border, demographics moving far out of favor, and an increase in interest rates that will drive up debt service costs, and you can see why deficits will rise. But nothing adds to the deficit like a recession. Our asset-bubble addicted economy faces another reduction in GDP growth very shortly. This factor alone will send deficits north of $1 trillion in short order.

Faced with a worldwide economic slump, central banks remain the only game in town. And today’s central banks, determined to smooth out every hiccup in the economy, only have one answer–print money. When all you have is a printing press, every problem looks like a monetary crisis.

The Fed will not be raising rates anytime soon. To the contrary, Ms. Yellen will soon be forced back into the money printing business in an attempt to; force higher money supply growth, push real interest rates further into negative territory, keep the dollar from rising, and to make sure debt service payments remain under control.

Very soon we will have a perfect storm in which gold will rise. The next phase in the gold bull market will include the four conditions of; negative real interest rates, rapid money supply growth, a falling dollar and skyrocketing deficits. Investors that have the foresight to realize this opportunity today stand to benefit greatly in the near future.

Michael Pento is the President and Founder of Pento Portfolio Strategies (PPS). PPS is a Registered Investment Advisory Firm that provides money management services and research for individual and institutional clients.

Michael is a well-established specialist in markets and economics and a regular guest on CNBC, CNN, Bloomberg, FOX Business News and other international media outlets. His market analysis can also be read in most major financial publications, including the Wall Street Journal. He also acts as a Financial Columnist for Forbes, Contributor to thestreet.com and is a blogger at the Huffington Post.

Prior to starting PPS, Michael served as a senior economist and vice president of the managed products division of Euro Pacific Capital. There, he also led an external sales division that marketed their managed products to outside broker-dealers and registered investment advisors.

Additionally, Michael has worked at an investment advisory firm where he helped create ETFs and UITs that were sold throughout Wall Street. Earlier in his career he spent two years on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange. He has carried series 7, 63, 65, 55 and Life and Health Insurance Licenses. Michael Pento graduated from Rowan University in 1991.

Become An Insider!

Sign up for Affluent Investor's free email newsletter and receive Jerry Bowyer's Special Report, "How to Be an Affluent Investor in the Age of Obama & Ineffectual Republican Opposition."



  • Jorge Herrera

    Thanks for your opinion Michael. It makes life interesting since it complete opposes Harry S Dent’s opinion. He argues that because of Demographics we are into the middle of a de-leveraging period caused specially by the Baby Boomer’s generation going into retiring and conserving the dollars they were able to accumulate. So because of demographics in the World and economic policies in Japan and Europe, the US is looking like the only safe heaven and that will strengthen the dollar which will push gold lower.
    Both yours and Dent’s arguments are very strong.
    I agree with gold as insurance but since we do not know how long the dollar can still be the strongest currency in the world we should pay attention to the Infinite Banking Concept that allows us to become the Bank.

  • RJ King

    We’ve heard this tune for the last two years. Jeff Currie was spot on with his prediction on gold. Goldman now controls the weather so there will be no more perfect storms.

  • How many tines has the best move been to do exactly the opposite of what GS says? I completely agree with the article and thesis of how and why metals move in relation to debt and or perceived confidence in “the system” or USD as world trade currency and petro dollar. What has really happened is that the massive debt created is what has pumped the markets and those cyber dollars are all that has held it all together, via that pump ? So it is all a giant illusion and only created an astounding near 20 trillion of nat debt and another 120 trillion of off balance sheet unfunded liabiliites that can never be repaid ? Numerically it is quite impossible and of course the 750 trillion of derivative are not even in the mix ? So why would anybody have any confidence in such a hose of cards ? Only the cheaters and cronys have prospered from the schemes and there will be a day of reckoning. It is all a giant ILLUSION ! so prepare accordingly.

The Affluent Mix

Become An Insider!

Sign up for Affluent Investor's free email newsletter and receive Jerry Bowyer's Special Report, "How to Be an Affluent Investor in the Age of Obama & Ineffectual Republican Opposition."